Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:deviation:
 


God is dead,
or so they say.
But, I ask you,
who are "they?"
Are they the same
who always claim
they're Athiests,
or Agnostics?
But, better yet,
Darwinists?
Who, then, is
the God that
they speak so
freely of?
How can God
be dead if
He was never
alive at all?
These people
don't believe
in any such God.
How, then, did
life begin?
A bang?
An Ape?
An accident?
All theories.
If life is so
very simple,
why is the
question complex?
God is dead,
or so they say.
And, I still ask
you, who are "they?"
©2007-2009 ~ladyshoshana
:iconladyshoshana:

Author's Comments

This quote is said by many, but believed by few.

So, where did it originate from?

I like to inspire critical thinking, and I hope this piece accomplishes just that.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconmylifeonstandby:
i have the same thoughts
you pretty much ripped those ideas
from my head but its cool
you did a great job
i really like the concept of god never existing
in the first place
:iconladyshoshana:
First of all...I am very grateful that you enjoyed this. It's kind of controversial, and I wasn't sure how people would react.

Second, I do hope that you don't hold anything against me for "ripping the ideas from your head." I truly didn't mean to take anyone's ideas.

Last, thank you for always giving me kind words of encouragement. I know that you truly mean them, because you only comment on the pieces that you truly enjoy. :hug:

--
Flickr
Self-Injury Club
CircleofFriends

:iconwalkingfish:
I personally love this. It really hits the heart of the statement and gives a very stable arguement. I'll have to remember this next time I hear someone say that.

--
There's a good reason why this signature is here, I just haven't figured it out yet.
~
this is a link to a MAGICAL place:[link]
:iconladyshoshana:
Wow, I think you have officially made my day.

That's really great to hear, that now you can take inspiration from this poem and use it to support your POV on something you feel strongly about.

I'm flattered. Thank you :hug:

--
Flickr
Self-Injury Club
CircleofFriends

:iconwalkingfish:
You're very welcome :D

--
There's a good reason why this signature is here, I just haven't figured it out yet.
~
this is a link to a MAGICAL place:[link]
:iconfatallover:
very interesting

--
"Hail to the Blue"
Le bleu Fleur





(\ /)
( . .)
c('')('')
CUtE BuNNy!
:icontearsamongashes:
"How can God be dead if He was never alive at all?"

Well-written, but I think you misunderstand Nietzsche's point. Have you read Thus Spoke Zarathustra? To the best of my knowledge, very few people say "god is dead" without understanding what the phrase means. I can't explain it better than Nietzsche, but this is basically how it works: society has been grounded on Judeo-Christian morality for centuries, but, as science and Enlightenment thinking began outstripping religious sentiment, the contrived "need" for a deity simultaneously decreased until society is no longer dependent on such superstitions. Therefore, if, for all practical purposes, god is irrelevant, why adhere to Judeo-Christian values any longer? This is why Nietzsche praised so highly the creation of new values and the destruction of old "tablets."

Thus, god is dead. Its existence is irrelevant to modern society, its influence mitigated and limited to religious adherents.

Judging from the nature of this poem, I'm assuming you're religious. Having been a Christian myself from the ages of six to eighteen, I understand your perspective; however, I can assure you that those who say "god is dead" do not literally mean that Jehovah or Zeus or Allah is deceased. The atheist contends that none of them ever existed, and, once this is recognized by society, the effect(s) of these gods on human culture should be nullified.
:iconladyshoshana:
Wow, Thank you very much for the explanation. :thanks:

I knew this was something Nietzsche had said, but I never really researched it in depth.

Let me say, I am glad you read the poem and took the time to really dig deep into it. I believe that's what poetry's supposed to be about.

Although I may have misrepresented the idea a bit, I believe the message still rings clear, as to my thoughts on the subject.

Again, thank you for the comment. :D

--
Flickr
Self-Injury Club
CircleofFriends

Details

April 27, 2007
793 bytes

Statistics

8
2 [who?]
25 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Share

Link
Thumb

Site Map